Protesting airport security and barking up the wrong tree
May 15th, 2008Standing at the ticket counter on my way to San Francisco last week I overheard the following exchange between a man and the lady behind the counter:
” … what if I don’t drive? You can’t require me to have a driver’s license, ” the man said.
The ticket agent said something softly about other forms of ID.
“This is not a fascist state. I don’t have to show you my ID, ” he replied angrily. Out of the corner of my eye I could see that she was uncomfortable, but keeping cool about it.
“Sir, we just need to see some form of ID.”
“This is fascism, ” he repeated. “We’re living in a fascist state. You have no right. ”
She remained calm, said nothing, and waited.
Seeing that she wasn’t going to budge, the man produced something for her and said, “I just want to inform you that you have no right to ask for my driver’s license.”
“And now you have, ” she replied.
The man went on his way and she turned to me.
“Do you have photo ID?” she said with a between-you-and-me smile. I didn’t give her any trouble.
The guy was right, though. They shouldn’t be able to treat every one like a terrorist or a criminal without cause. But he was barking up the wrong tree. He was venting his frustrations with the goverment at a person who was only doing her job. His anger enacted no change, served no end.
The unfortunate possibility is that maybe she agreed with him wholeheartedly. After all, he cannot have been the first enraged customer to voice that complaint, and considering the intelligence I saw in her eyes I imagine those complaints did not fall on deaf ears. But she has a job to keep and bills to pay. Maybe she gets up every day and dreads that she’ll have to bury her personal convictions and enforce laws and policies in which she does not believe. And maybe she also dreads the wrath of those who would throw that in her face.
But probably not.


